Exclusive vs shared mortgage leads: which is better for brokers?

Shared leads are sold to several lenders at once. Exclusive leads come only to your team. Here is how they compare on cost, speed and control.

By Aman Anand, Co-founder of Sunsky Marketing · Updated · 6 min read
Exclusive vs shared mortgage leads: which is better for brokers?
Short answer

Shared mortgage leads are sold to several lenders, so you pay less per lead but race other loan officers for every borrower. Exclusive leads go only to your team, cost more per lead or require your own ads, and usually convert better. Compare them by cost per funded loan, not cost per lead.

What is a shared mortgage lead?

A shared lead is a borrower inquiry that a lead marketplace sells to more than one lender. The borrower fills out one form on a comparison site, and several loan officers receive the same name, phone number and loan details at roughly the same time.

LendingTree, the best-known marketplace, describes its service as finding up to five lenders that match a borrower's request. For the borrower that means choice. For each lender it means competition: the first loan officer to reach the borrower usually wins the conversation.

What is an exclusive mortgage lead?

An exclusive lead goes to one brokerage only. There are two kinds:

Exclusive vs shared leads at a glance

Shared leadsVendor-exclusive leadsFirst-party exclusive leads
Who receives the leadSeveral lendersYour teamYour team
How you payPer leadPer lead, usually higherAd spend plus setup or management
Typical priceAbout $30–$100 (LendingTree), $100–$200 (Bankrate)1Quoted by vendorDepends on market, ad spend and funnel
Speed pressureVery high, you race other lendersModerateModerate, you control follow-up
Who owns the dataThe marketplaceThe vendorYour brokerage
Volume controlBuy more any dayLimited by vendor supplyScale by budget and creative

1 Per-lead price ranges reported by HousingWire. Prices vary by state, loan type and filters.

Why speed matters so much with shared leads

Harvard Business Review's study of 1.25 million sales leads found that companies that contacted a lead within an hour were nearly seven times as likely to qualify it as companies that waited even one hour longer, and more than 60 times as likely as companies that waited 24 hours or more (HBR, 2011).

With a shared lead, that clock is running for every lender who bought the same borrower. If your team cannot call within minutes, around the clock, you are paying full price for a lead someone else is likely to win. Exclusive leads still reward speed, but you are not racing four other loan officers to the same phone number.

When shared leads make sense

When exclusive leads are the better choice

Compare sources by cost per funded loan, not cost per lead

A cheap lead that rarely closes is expensive. The fair comparison is what each source costs you for every loan that actually funds:

Cost per funded loan = total spend on the source ÷ loans funded from it

For example, if you spent $6,000 on one source last quarter and it produced three funded loans, it cost $2,000 per funded loan. Run the same math for every source, including your own ads, before deciding where the next dollar goes. These numbers are an illustration, not a benchmark. Your own CRM data is what counts.

How Sunsky approaches it

Sunsky Marketing builds first-party exclusive lead flow for mortgage brokers: ads in accounts you own, pre-qualification pages for each loan program, instant text and email follow-up, and weekly reporting on leads, applications and funded loans. We have run lead generation for more than 50 mortgage brokers across the United States.

Want leads only your team gets?Book a free 30-minute lead gen audit with the founders.

Book your free audit

Frequently asked questions

Are exclusive mortgage leads worth the higher price?

Often, yes, because you are not competing with other lenders for the same borrower. Judge it by cost per funded loan from your own data rather than by the price of a single lead.

How many lenders get a shared mortgage lead?

It depends on the marketplace. LendingTree says it finds up to five lenders for a borrower's request, so a single inquiry can reach several loan officers.

How fast should a loan officer call a new lead?

As fast as possible, ideally within minutes. Harvard Business Review found that contacting a lead within an hour made qualifying it nearly seven times more likely than waiting an hour longer (HBR).

Can I run exclusive leads and shared leads at the same time?

Yes. Many brokers keep a small shared-lead budget for volume while they build their own exclusive lead flow, then shift budget toward whichever source has the lower cost per funded loan.

Sources

Related